Page 5 of 7

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Feb 22, 2017 7:26 am
by blahblah
Urawa completed wiped the floor with the Wanderers and Muangthong played well against Brisbane for their point.

Shanghai's away win against Seoul was bit of surprise.

Re: RE: Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Feb 22, 2017 9:49 am
by bpowell454
Urawa completed wiped the floor with the Wanderers and Muangthong played well against Brisbane for their point.

Shanghai's away win against Seoul was bit of surprise.
WSW only shot of the game was at 93 mins from about 30 yards out, went about 10 metres over the goal.

0-4

Re: RE: Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Feb 22, 2017 10:02 am
by Stuckey
Urawa completed wiped the floor with the Wanderers and Muangthong played well against Brisbane for their point.

Shanghai's away win against Seoul was bit of surprise.
WSW only shot of the game was at 93 mins from about 30 yards out, went about 10 metres over the goal.

0-4
After the week WSW have had. I've got to say that's a little bit of justice right there.

:lol:

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 12:00 am
by sevengoals
Hammered again!

Ulsan Hyundai (Kor) 6 - 0 Brisbane Roar (Aus)

Shanghai SIPG (Chn) 5 - 1 WS Wanderers (Aus)

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 7:05 am
by blahblah
The A-League clubs have been on the receiving end of some serious shellackings.

Our old mates from Uzbekistan, Bunyodkor, went down 2-3 to Al-Ain as well :(

Oddly enough I get the feeling we may go ok tonight as our squad seems to be gelling. The Kim effect?

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 9:29 am
by Stuckey
Hammered again!

Ulsan Hyundai (Kor) 6 - 0 Brisbane Roar (Aus)

Shanghai SIPG (Chn) 5 - 1 WS Wanderers (Aus)
Wow. If the FFA needed an indication the HAL has gone backwards they have it.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 1:00 pm
by shinAUFC
Bozza and rudan getting stuck in again calling it a dark day for aussie football. I disagree, its a simple case of economics.

There is big money in china, korea, japan and even thailand. Their best players do not leave for europe apart from the absolute elite like kagawa and honda instead they stay in asia and contribute to their leagues depth.

Then their mid teir players rarely seek a move overseas until their career is on the slide, take aufcs current import Kim for example.

Now compare this to australia, our half promising youth leave for europe upon the first offer they get. Our mid tier players are chasing big money in asia and our best are all in europe.

The only way this will change is if more money comes to aussie football and filters into the clubs. We ARE NOT behind these ither countries interms of football quality, but infrastructure and investment we are lacking.

If every aussie who was not playing in one of the top 5 leagues came back home to the aleague we would be very competitive in asia.

Rudes and bozza need to compare apples with apples.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 4:10 pm
by View From The Top
Well said Shin. Its not just that their better players are playing in their leagues but also the fact that the teams are more stable and are not changing half their players every year or two - this is a huge benefit for team cohesion and effectiveness as a unit.

No way is our side in the ACL the same one that won the A-League last season, which is a huge shame.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 7:12 pm
by Ghost
WSW and we are struggling in the A-league, no where the teams of last season.
Brisbane is a mid table A-league team this season, a long way behind the top two and probably Perth as well.

Still Brisbane managed a great result to get to the group stage even though they got thrashed last night.

I think the current Sydney team would do much better as would our team and WSW's team from last season.

I don't think there is any need to panic but there is a need to keep working hard to ensure the A-league keeps improving.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 9:29 pm
by sevengoals
We need more games and more clubs.
Simple.
FFA is failing to deliver.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 11:08 pm
by Stuckey
Bozza and rudan getting stuck in again calling it a dark day for aussie football. I disagree, its a simple case of economics.

There is big money in china, korea, japan and even thailand. Their best players do not leave for europe apart from the absolute elite like kagawa and honda instead they stay in asia and contribute to their leagues depth.

Then their mid teir players rarely seek a move overseas until their career is on the slide, take aufcs current import Kim for example.

Now compare this to australia, our half promising youth leave for europe upon the first offer they get. Our mid tier players are chasing big money in asia and our best are all in europe.

The only way this will change is if more money comes to aussie football and filters into the clubs. We ARE NOT behind these ither countries interms of football quality, but infrastructure and investment we are lacking.

If every aussie who was not playing in one of the top 5 leagues came back home to the aleague we would be very competitive in asia.

Rudes and bozza need to compare apples with apples.
Disagree sorry. Those leagues have been holding their players back due to high wages for sometime not just the last couple of seasons. HAL clubs have shown they can match it many times in the past. Obviously this is a one off, but I think its an indication that the standard of HAL clubs (which are obviously made up of local players) isn't progressing the same as other leagues (which is also made up of local players generally).
Just like how the youth NTs continue to decline. As do HAL clubs in Asia.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 11:35 pm
by blahblah
Strange thing is that ever since I've dragged myself from the sea-side drinking establishment to the sea-side house (Tarawa is about 500m at its widest) we've looked like the side in ascendancy.

EDIT: Not only did I post this in the wrong thread, Elrich 'scored' a soon as I tried to edit it. Perhaps for the sake of the team I shall stay here :)

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Wed Mar 01, 2017 11:39 pm
by blahblah
Oh bugger, 2-0. I'm moving.

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Thu Mar 02, 2017 1:17 am
by shinAUFC
Bozza and rudan getting stuck in again calling it a dark day for aussie football. I disagree, its a simple case of economics.

There is big money in china, korea, japan and even thailand. Their best players do not leave for europe apart from the absolute elite like kagawa and honda instead they stay in asia and contribute to their leagues depth.

Then their mid teir players rarely seek a move overseas until their career is on the slide, take aufcs current import Kim for example.

Now compare this to australia, our half promising youth leave for europe upon the first offer they get. Our mid tier players are chasing big money in asia and our best are all in europe.

The only way this will change is if more money comes to aussie football and filters into the clubs. We ARE NOT behind these ither countries interms of football quality, but infrastructure and investment we are lacking.

If every aussie who was not playing in one of the top 5 leagues came back home to the aleague we would be very competitive in asia.

Rudes and bozza need to compare apples with apples.
Disagree sorry. Those leagues have been holding their players back due to high wages for sometime not just the last couple of seasons. HAL clubs have shown they can match it many times in the past. Obviously this is a one off, but I think its an indication that the standard of HAL clubs (which are obviously made up of local players) isn't progressing the same as other leagues (which is also made up of local players generally).
Just like how the youth NTs continue to decline. As do HAL clubs in Asia.
Only 2 coubs have been succesful in acl from aus and bith aufc and wsw played defensive counter attacking football and more often than not found a way to win despite being outplayed.

When aussie teams strive to play good football in acl and win by doing so then i think its a fair assesment

Re: 2017 Asian Champions League

Posted: Thu Mar 02, 2017 4:32 pm
by Stuckey
Bozza and rudan getting stuck in again calling it a dark day for aussie football. I disagree, its a simple case of economics.

There is big money in china, korea, japan and even thailand. Their best players do not leave for europe apart from the absolute elite like kagawa and honda instead they stay in asia and contribute to their leagues depth.

Then their mid teir players rarely seek a move overseas until their career is on the slide, take aufcs current import Kim for example.

Now compare this to australia, our half promising youth leave for europe upon the first offer they get. Our mid tier players are chasing big money in asia and our best are all in europe.

The only way this will change is if more money comes to aussie football and filters into the clubs. We ARE NOT behind these ither countries interms of football quality, but infrastructure and investment we are lacking.

If every aussie who was not playing in one of the top 5 leagues came back home to the aleague we would be very competitive in asia.

Rudes and bozza need to compare apples with apples.
Disagree sorry. Those leagues have been holding their players back due to high wages for sometime not just the last couple of seasons. HAL clubs have shown they can match it many times in the past. Obviously this is a one off, but I think its an indication that the standard of HAL clubs (which are obviously made up of local players) isn't progressing the same as other leagues (which is also made up of local players generally).
Just like how the youth NTs continue to decline. As do HAL clubs in Asia.
Only 2 coubs have been succesful in acl from aus and bith aufc and wsw played defensive counter attacking football and more often than not found a way to win despite being outplayed.

When aussie teams strive to play good football in acl and win by doing so then i think its a fair assesment
I think BlahBlah would be better suited to answering this, but I would suggest that few sides that win the ACL do so playing attacking possession based football. Stout defending and clinical finishing often seems to be what gets the points in Asia.
So I don't think many sides in Asia would back themselves to maintain possession and pressure against the champion of China or Korea.
IMO the thing that mainly holds Australian clubs back is that lack of squad HAL clubs have. 23 players isn't enough to be competitive on two fronts. If HAL clubs sign 4-6 more players when they join the ACL I believe they would be far more competitive.
Personally I think this is a rule the FFA should allow. That once a club makes the ACL group stage they are able to sign 3 additional players for that season. Personally I wouldn't see this as a massive advantage for those clubs. It would just make the playing field fairer for the clubs taking part in the ACL.