Is Andy Harper the worst commentator??

[RedLaird]

watching the Brisbane,Heart game tonight it has become very apparent Andy Harper is not only a moron but very definitely one of the worse commentators I have ever listened to.Unless you are from an east coast team then your goals are only from bad play from the opponent.To defend Berisha tonight when his studs were up from the moment he he left the ground till they connected with Vedalphi and to say he only was going for goal shows what a moron this man is.Sure it's a whinge but now I feel better Time for another beer me thinks.But surely he is the worse or are there even worser(could be a word).

[shinAUFC]

I would normally agree with you but from what i can here on the highlight package that is robbie slater

[Stuckey]

Its sad that Harper's commentating takes away from his record as one of the greatest goal scorers in NSL history.

One thing I find hilarious about Slater is his phoney excited voice when every goal goes in.

[EdDog]

Slater is atrocious. Harper slightly better.

We need commentators that just call the game, not their opinions.

[Interloper]

Slater and Harper are fine, not great though. They only stand out because they are on the opposite side of ideal from the pseudo-intellectual wankfest that comprises written coverage of the sport.